Cars

Opel Astra against VW Golf: the hybrid versions in the first comparison

Next please! Dancers, actors and musicians know the three painful words with which they are sent off the stage after a few minutes of audition. The new Astra doesn’t have to be afraid of that today, for the debut, the compact Opel is thoroughly inspected inside and out, standing and driving.

Buy new cars online

Opel Astra plug-in hybrid

Opel Astra plug-in hybrid at carwow.de

Get the best offers for the Opel Astra plug-in hybrid and save up to €9966 compared to the RRP at carwow.de.


During the AUTO BILD Test the Best event on the Bridgestone site south of Rome, we took the opportunity to compare the Astra L, which is still being built in Rüsselsheim, with the Golf. You can indeed be a bit afraid of him, the Wolfsburg player continues to finish one test after the other as the winner. The self-confident appearance of the Astra, which is nine centimeters longer and a whopping eight centimeters wider than the Golf, cannot do any harm.
Opel Astra Plug-in Hybrid VW Golf 1.4 eHybrid

Strong appearance: The Astra can keep up very well with the Golf in terms of looks – it makes a thoroughly impressive impression.


The Astra is imposing and independent

The EMP2 platform, which it now shares with its brothers Peugeot 308, Citroën C4 and DS 4, may strike the trained eye. Nevertheless, the new Astra is not only visually impressive, but also unique. Even more gratifying for Astra fans: we don’t have to search a long time before we find something that the Astra can do better than the Golf. Door open and slammed again – that sounds richer than the somewhat shabby doors of the VW.
Opel Astra Plug-in Hybrid

Better to use: In the new Opel Astra we still find real buttons and a rotary control – unfortunately the Golf lacks that.


Classic operation is much more intuitive

As soon as you get in, the Golf reveals further weaknesses: using the slider is a test of patience for some drivers. Since the fixed keys in the Astra are a blessing. Smart: A short video on the central display explains the basic operation. But even without a tutorial, you can quickly find your way around the Astra thanks to easy-to-reach buttons including a favorites function and a simple menu structure. Great: the high-resolution image from the swiveling reversing camera, the thick rotary control for the volume, the pushbuttons for the seat heating and the separate air conditioning controls – none of this is available in the Golf.
junction

Engine type/cylinder

junction

junction

installation position

junction

junction

valves/camshafts

junction

junction

Battery capacity kWh

junction

junction

displacement

junction

junction

System power kW (hp)

junction

junction

System torque Nm

junction

junction

V max

junction

junction

transmission

junction

junction

drive

junction

junction

Brakes front/rear

junction

junction

test car tires

junction

junction

tire type

junction

junction

wheel size

junction

junction

Exhaust gas CO2*

junction

junction

Consumption*

junction

junction

tank capacity

junction

junction

fuel grade

junction

junction

electric range*

junction

junction

Energy consumption kWh/100km*

junction

junction

trailer load used/unused

junction

junction

drawbar load

junction

junction

trunk volume

junction

junction

Length Width Height

junction

junction

wheelbase

junction

junction

base price***

junction

junction

Test car price*** (is evaluated)

junction

Four-cylinder, turbo, + electric motor

4374/1860-k. A.**/1442mm

Four-cylinder, turbo, + electric motor

4284/1789-2017**/1482mm


It’s just a pity that you have to look for the somewhat small temperature display on the central screen of the Astra. The digital instrument cluster, on the other hand, pleases with its simple operation and clear display. The only thing we miss is a classic view with round instruments like in the Golf. With both, the voice control can be activated by voice command. Everything works to some extent, but a little better in Wolfsburg. In addition, the Opel system does not understand who is speaking. The driver’s buttocks always warm up when the “seat heating on” command is given. The Golf, on the other hand, also recognizes when the passenger has cold buttocks.

Vattenfall wall boxes

Vattenfall Wallbox

Vattenfall wallbox + green electricity

Vattenfall charging packages including inexpensive wall boxes with a hardware bonus: Charge Amps Halo™ from 299 euros

In co-operation with

Vattenfall logo


More important: the place in the second row. The Golf has more to offer despite being shorter and having a shorter wheelbase. The flatter rear and side windows of the Astra also restrict all-round visibility and the feeling of space – we already know this from the 308.

VW Golf 1.4 eHybrid

Faster: From a speed of 130, the Golf pulls away from its competitor. The drive is always acoustically present over and over strokes.


With performance advantage, the Golf is faster

The small performance deficit of 24 hp is irrelevant in everyday life, even if the Golf pulls away from the Astra at speeds of 130 and above. Too bad: Despite the lower speed level, the Astra is louder inside. In both, the four-cylinder works a bit rough under full load, but the 1.6 of the Astra looks a bit more cultivated. No wonder, the hybrid drive including 1.4 petrol engine in the Golf is now quite old.
junction

acceleration

junction

junction

0-50km/h

junction

junction

0-100km/h

junction

junction

0-130km/h

junction

junction

0-160km/h

junction

junction

intermediate sprint

junction

junction

60-100km/h

junction

junction

80-120km/h

junction

junction

curb weight (manufacturer)

junction

junction

Turning circle left/right

junction

junction

seat height

junction

junction

braking distance

junction

junction

from 100 km/h cold

junction

junction

from 100 km/h warm

junction

junction

interior noise

junction

junction

at 50 km/h

junction

junction

at 100km/h

junction

junction

at 130 km/h

junction


Tricky with hybrids: the transitions between electric and combustion mode. For both, the vote seems relatively successful. However, even in the compact class, this is still a bit smoother. The Golf shows clear advantages with its much more direct steering, which reduces cranking when maneuvering and is therefore more comfortable. And because the Golf also has an adjustable chassis, it makes a more confident impression when driving in the test configuration.
Opel Astra Plug-in Hybrid

Neat: The Astra is a good all-rounder when it comes to tuning, but the Golf leaves a slightly more confident impression


When it comes to the chassis, the Opel is a little behind

The all-round properties of the Astra chassis are still impressive, even if the Opel takes short bumps in particular a little stiffer. Thoroughly polished, this new Astra, which certainly does not have to be waved off the stage after the first audition. Thanks to the lower costs, it ends up almost level with its archrival. Full of excitement we say: Next, please! And mean the next test.

picture gallery

camera

Opel Astra versus VW Golf


Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button